On August 7,2025, a British Columbia Supreme Court Justice rendered a very disturbing judgment on a Judicial Review of a decision made by the Hospital Appeal Board that has been building with intensity over the past 3 years. In essence, this judgment declares that health authorities have the unrestricted jurisdiction to penalize in a disciplinary manner those who exercise their Charter Rights, including that of Informed Consent, in refusing a medical treatment being imposed upon them against their will.
On October 26, 2021, Dr. Bonnie Henry (British Columbia’s Provincial Health Officer) issued a mandate that all healthcare practitioners working in a healthcare facility must submit to the enforced injection of the COVID “vaccination” in order to continue working in the healthcare facility, or alternatively, to cease working in the healthcare facility. Even though there was no proven efficacy or safety record at the time for these vaccinations, no exemptions were allowed, including those based on religious beliefs. A relatively large number of physicians, based on their Charter Right to refuse a personal medical treatment on the basis of informed consent, refused to be coerced into receiving a treatment they did not want, despite the recognized threat of loss of income, collegiality with their peers and co-workers and professional respect. Nonetheless, even while refusing the treatment, they complied with the enforcement of the mandate and removed themselves from healthcare facilities around the province in all health authorities.
Subsequently, the provincial health authorities contravened their own Bylaws by formally disciplining these physicians for refusing a personal medical treatment, stating that they were in “breach of contract”. Not only were these physicians not allowed to work in a BC healthcare institution such as hospitals and long-term care facilities, but their hospital privileges were formally terminated as a disciplinary, penalizing measure. As a result, each physician has sustained a “black mark” on their College of Physicians and Surgeons BC licensure record, which stands to this day.
Now that the original mandate has been lifted, in order to work in a BC healthcare facility once again, these physicians must apply for hospital privileges as NEW applicants. However, as many of their positions have been filled due to recruitment efforts during the intervening years, they are unlikely to re-enter their previous position, or work with their previous colleagues. IN ADDITION, they continue to carry the “black mark” on their licenses because of the formal discipline rendered by their Health Authorities, despite being 100% compliant with the Mandate’s terms (of not working in a healthcare facility while the mandate was being enforced).
Being greatly concerned about this violation of Charter Rights and the implications going forward, Dr. Theresa Szezepaniak, along with her legal team, represented these physicians in her Supreme Court Judicial Review case in mid-June, 2025. This case essentially challenged the premise that authorities can attempt to coerce, and then subsequently penalize individuals who exercise their charter right in making an informed decision to withhold consent for a personal medical treatment.
This case was finally heard in BC’s Supreme Court in June of 2025, and the Judgment was rendered in early August, 2025. The decision to support these health authorities in their actions has devastating consequences going forward for not only healthcare professionals, but ALL CITIZENS who choose to withhold consent for a personal medical treatment, such that disciplinary penalization is justified if the authorities deem it to be so, regardless of an individual’s Charter Rights.
This decision is now being appealed to the BC Court of Appeal, but the financial legal costs will be significant. Up until now, the physicians involved in this battle have personally funded their legal representation. In addition, the lawyers involved have sacrificed hundreds of pro bono hours towards this cause. However, the financial consequences have become almost overwhelming and this, coupled with the loss of income during the pandemic years, has led to our appeal to you for financial support.
We are asking for your financial contribution toward the cause. This is something that AFFECTS ALL OF US. This case will give the Court of Appeal an opportunity to rule on whether the Charter applies to disciplinary action carried out by Health Authorities against physicians and other health care workers. It will determine if our Charter Right to exercise informed consent free of coercion or pressure from the state is still valid in Canada. It will affect all government decision makers and those who work within, or are regulated by, Government or their delegates. THIS IS VITALLY IMPORTANT TO EVERY CITIZEN!
Please send your pledged donation by e-transfer to CSSEM@protonmail.com
or by regular mail via cheque to: PO Box 78045 Port Coquitlam RPO Northside, BC V3B 7H5. Please send a note with your donation indicating that the funds are to be used for the ongoing “Physicians’ Legal Battle”.


